Two kinds of fog: radiation and advection
Two kinds of fog matter for vineyards. Radiation fog forms on clear, calm nights, when the ground loses heat and cools the air beside it below its dew point. It is patchy, tends to stay where it forms, is favoured in sheltered valleys and near bodies of water, and burns off once the sun warms the ground. Advection fog forms when warm, moist air moves over a colder surface and is cooled from below until it is saturated. It can form under cloud and in moderate to strong wind, it can last for days, and it is most common on the US West Coast.
The difference matters because the two fogs do different things to a vineyard. Radiation fog belongs to a calm, clear night, the same kind of night that cools the ground and can bring frost. Advection fog is a weather pattern that can cool a whole district through the day.
Napa: sea fog that cools by day
Napa Valley has a Mediterranean climate in which the south of the valley is cooled by marine breezes and fog from San Pablo Bay and the Petaluma Gap. In Los Carneros, summer highs rarely exceed 80 °F (27 °C), while in Calistoga, at the northern end, daytime summer temperatures may exceed 100 °F (38 °C). The difference between the cooler south and the warmer north is 10 °F (about 6 °C) or more.
Fog and cool air carried inland by sea breezes is advection fog in meteorological terms, although growers speak simply of fog and breezes. This cooling is regional and works through the day, so it shapes which grapes and styles suit a district. It is a different effect from the local one of a lake, described below.
Napa Valley summer daytime highs: in Los Carneros rarely above 80 °F (27 °C), in Calistoga possibly above 100 °F (38 °C). The bars show these thresholds, not measured averages.
Read the figure as text
Summer daytime high (°F)
- Los Carneros: rarely above: 80 °F
- Calistoga: may exceed: 100 °F
Cold air drains downhill: valley floors can be frost pockets
On a calm, clear night the soil radiates heat to the sky, the air nearest the ground cools, and this cold, dense air flows downhill and pools in low spots. The result is a temperature inversion, with the coldest air on the vineyard floor. A slope speeds the drainage unless something blocks the flow. Cold-air drainage leaves mid-slope sites warmer than the valley floor, and in the Finger Lakes slope and air drainage reduce spring and fall frost and winter injury, while flat or bottom sites suffered serious injury in freezes that hillsides came through with normal crops.
So a river valley is not simply a warm place. Its floor can host radiation fog, which is favoured in sheltered valleys and near water, and it can collect cold air, while the slope above stays warmer. A large body of water that stores heat is a separate effect, and it works the other way; which one dominates depends on scale and site.
A valley seen from the side. Cold, dense air flows down the slope and pools on the floor, where radiation fog can form; the slope above stays warmer, and a deep lake stores heat. Shapes are illustrative; no temperatures are shown.
Read the figure as text
- Mid-slope — Cold air drains away, so frost risk is lower than on the valley floor
- Valley-floor fog — Radiation fog is favoured in sheltered valleys and near water
- Deep lake — Stores heat: cooler than the air in summer, warmer in autumn and winter
- Cold air drains downhill — On calm, clear nights it flows down the slope and pools in low spots
River mist and noble rot: Sauternes and Barsac
Sauternes and Barsac lie on the left bank of the Garonne, where the small river Ciron flows into it. In autumn, the meeting of the waters brings morning mist over the vines, and this favours Botrytis cinerea, the noble rot that concentrates the sugar in the berries.
The mist is necessary but not sufficient. Humid mornings followed by warm, sunny afternoons that dry the grapes give noble rot, while prolonged rain or humidity gives grey rot. A peer-reviewed study of Botrytis on Garganega grapes names the same pair of conditions: humid nights, foggy mornings and dry, sunny days for noble rot, strong rain or humidity for grey rot.
Growers often explain the mist by the difference in temperature between the cooler Ciron and the Garonne.
Langhe nebbia: a name and a harvest tradition
The name Nebbiolo is said to come from nebbia, the Italian word for fog. There are two explanations: the bloom on the berries, or the fact that the variety ripens so late that the harvest meets the first autumn fogs. Nebbiolo ripens in the first half of October and does best on hillsides between 200 and 450 m, facing south to south-west and sheltered from frost.
The fog here is a naming and harvest-season tradition. The tradition surrounding the name alone does not establish how fog affects the ripening or quality of Nebbiolo. As general meteorology, autumn valley fog is usually radiation fog, but that is not a measured finding for the Langhe. What can be stated in measurable terms is height, aspect and frost shelter, which connect to the cold-air drainage described above.
Large lakes store heat: the Finger Lakes
Large lakes have a large capacity to store heat. They are cooler than the air in spring and summer and warmer than the air in autumn and winter, so they moderate the air temperature near them and also affect wind and humidity.
This applies to the four larger Finger Lakes: Canandaigua, Keuka, Seneca and Cayuga. They are 300 to 650 feet deep (about 90 to 200 m) and rarely freeze. Though much smaller than the Great Lakes, they moderate winter lows and buffer temperatures at sites within a few miles. Seneca and Cayuga give the most moderation; Keuka and Canandaigua give less, with earlier autumn frost at higher elevations.
The moderation is partial: severe winter injury to vinifera vines still occurs about once a decade, and slope and air drainage still matter. The scale is also worth keeping apart: a lake effect reaches a few miles, while the sea fog of Napa is regional.
Lakes in Switzerland and Italy
Lavaux: UNESCO inscribed about 30 km of south-facing vineyard terraces on the north shore of Lake Geneva, from Chillon to Lausanne, in 2007. Local tradition speaks of “three suns”: direct sunshine, light reflected from the lake, and heat stored in the terrace walls and released at night. This is a local, traditional explanation, not a measured one. How much sunlight a water surface reflects depends strongly on the angle of the sun. The lake’s heat storage in general is documented (see above); the reflected light is not quantified.
Lake Neuchâtel: Vaud’s vineyards lie around Lakes Geneva, Neuchâtel and Morat, and Bonvillars, on the Vaud shore of Lake Neuchâtel, is said to be favoured by the lake’s thermal advantages. The Swiss federal climate-adaptation programme lists a pilot project in which the University of Neuchâtel studies viticulture on the lake shores under rising temperatures.
Lake Garda: the Bardolino area has a temperate, sub-continental climate shaped by Lake Garda, the moraine hills and Monte Baldo, in which the lake attenuates temperature swings and breezes ventilate the vines. Mediterranean, continental and mountain microclimates occur within one area, and zonation work (2002 to 2007) defined the Montebaldo, La Rocca and Sommacampagna subzones.
Rivers as heat buffers: Mosel, Rhine and Loire
The Mosel is a region of steep, terraced slopes above the river, where slate stores daytime heat and releases it at night. The Rheingau lies in the Taunus foothills, with south-facing slopes along the stretch where the Rhine runs east to west between Wiesbaden and Rüdesheim. The Rhine is often called a reflector and a heat store for those slopes; this is a traditional explanation, not a measured one. The Loire has a temperate maritime climate that becomes more continental away from the river.
In these three cases the explanations are slope, aspect, rock and distance from the Atlantic. The river’s own contribution as a heat buffer is not measured, and the cold-air pooling described earlier shows that a valley can also be colder than the slope above it.
The mechanisms of this article by scale, by what supports them and by how firmly. “Supported” means a weather service, university or appellation body states it; “Traditional” means it is repeated locally without measurement.
Read the figure as text
| Scale | What supports it | Treat as | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cold-air drainage | One slope or valley | UC ANR, Penn State, Cornell | Supported |
| Deep-lake heat storage | A few miles from the shore | NOAA GLERL, Cornell | Supported |
| Marine fog | A whole district, by day | Napa Valley Vintners, NWS definition | Described by growers |
| River mist and noble rot | Vineyards beside the rivers | CIVB, peer-reviewed study | Supported, with dry afternoons |
| Lake reflection | Terraces by a lake | Local bodies only | Traditional |
| Fog and Nebbiolo | Harvest season in the Langhe | Consortium, naming tradition | Traditional |
Exercise: valley floor or slope above a lake?
[Question]
A grower compares two sites: a flat site beside a small river on a valley floor, and a mid-slope site a few miles from a deep lake. Explain what fog, cold air and heat storage may do at each site, and separate what is supported by weather and farm sources from what is tradition.
[Model answer]
On the valley floor, radiation fog is favoured in sheltered valleys and near water, and cold, dense air drains downhill and pools there, so the floor is the coldest part of the site and carries the greater frost risk. River mist helps noble rot only when it is followed by dry, sunny afternoons. On the mid-slope, air drainage keeps the site warmer than the floor, and a deep lake within a few miles stores heat and moderates winter lows, although severe winter injury can still occur about once a decade. Supported: the meteorological definitions of the two fogs, cold-air drainage on slopes, and lake moderation in the Finger Lakes. Tradition: lake reflection (“three suns”), the river as a reflector, and fog as a cause of Nebbiolo’s quality.
[Mark scheme (6 marks)]
• Explains radiation fog and cold-air pooling on the valley floor, and the condition for noble rot (2 marks)
• Explains the warmer mid-slope and the lake’s heat storage, with its limits and its reach of a few miles (2 marks)
• Separates supported mechanisms from traditional explanations, with examples (2 marks)
Fog
- Radiation fog: a clear, calm night cools the air
- Advection fog: moist air moves over a cold surface
- Mist helps noble rot only with dry, sunny afternoons
Water
- Large, deep lakes store heat
- The moderation reaches a few miles
- Reflection claims are traditional
Slope
- Cold air drains downhill and pools
- Mid-slope stays warmer than the floor
- Check the source of each claim
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between radiation fog and advection fog?
Radiation fog forms on clear, calm nights when the ground cools the air below its dew point; it is patchy and burns off with the sun. Advection fog forms when warm, moist air moves over a colder surface; it can occur under cloud and in wind and can last for days (US National Weather Service).
Does fog cause noble rot?
Not by itself. Morning mist favours Botrytis cinerea in Sauternes and Barsac, but noble rot needs humid mornings followed by warm, sunny, drying afternoons. Prolonged rain or humidity gives grey rot instead (Bordeaux wine council, CIVB).
Do lakes really make vineyards warmer?
Large, deep lakes store heat and moderate the air temperature within a few miles; in the Finger Lakes the moderation is partial, and severe winter injury still occurs about once a decade (Cornell). The idea that lakes reflect extra sunlight onto the vines is a local, traditional explanation that is not quantified.
Sources
- NOAA National Weather Service — Radiation Fog
- NOAA National Weather Service — Advection Fog
- UC ANR — Frost Protection Practices in Vineyards
- Penn State Extension — Understanding and Preventing Spring Frost and Freeze Damage to Grapes
- Napa Valley Vintners — Napa Valley Climate
- Vins de Bordeaux (CIVB) — What Is Noble Rot?
- Syndicat viticole de Sauternes et Barsac — The wines
- Frontiers in Plant Science via PMC — The Induction of Noble Rot (Botrytis cinerea) Infection during Postharvest Withering Changes the Metabolome of Grapevine Berries (Garganega)
- Consorzio di Tutela Barolo Barbaresco Alba Langhe e Dogliani — Nebbiolo
- NOAA GLERL — Climate and Hydrology of the Great Lakes (hydrometeorology section)
- Cornell Cooperative Extension Finger Lakes Grape Program — Site Selection
- Cornell CALS — New York Grape Growing Regions
- UNESCO World Heritage Centre — Lavaux, Vineyard Terraces
- Lavaux Patrimoine mondial (association) — The vineyard
- Chasselas.ch — The Chasselas wine regions
- Swiss Confederation (NCCS) — D.01 Viticulture on Lake Neuchâtel (climate adaptation pilot project)
- Consorzio di Tutela Chiaretto e Bardolino — Zonation and microclimates
- German Wine Institute (DWI) — Mosel (wine region)
- German Wine Institute (DWI) — Rheingau (wine region)
- InterLoire — Loire Valley wines (protected geographical names)
